Ratings
5
out of 5
260
user ratings
Your rating
or to rate this recipe.
Have you cooked this?
or to mark this recipe as cooked.
Private Notes
Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.
Cooking Notes
Elizabeth
It's amazing if you roast the pepper.
Karen L Davis
Hmmm. Loved the roasted pepper base. Salad a little looser than the in the pic, even with refrigeration. Next time might use a bit less lemon juice (2t)? Rather than taking the mortar and pestle route, used anchovy paste and added salt to the garlic press while crushing it. On tasting, felt tuna was a bit bland, so added a bit of both fresh, snipped dill and chives. Better.
Gillian
I didn't use the pepper at all and didn't miss it, but agree: The tuna salad part is really tasty. I thought I'd miss the mayo, but no! One warning: Do slow down long enough to rinse the anchovy. I didn't, but def. will next time. Otherwise a bit salty.
Susan Alexander
Terrific. A nice change from the standard tuna salad. Used jarred roasted peppers which were fine. Could also use a scooped out tomato. Perfect for lunch or as an appetizer - follow with Chicken Provencal for example. Will definitely make again. PS I am addicted to anchovies so not optional for me.
kate watts
Delicious. Used high quality tuna packed in water. Almost used jarred red peppers but was glad I didn’t. The texture of the pepper charred over a flame is important. Will be part of our household rotation.
kate watts
Delicious. Used high quality tuna packed in water. Almost used jarred red peppers but was glad I didn’t. The texture of the pepper charred over a flame is important. Will be part of our household rotation.
Ted
Forget tuna. Roast pepper after halving and cleaning filled with shallots, capers, salt,pepper, olive oil
SDGal
It seems I am the only one who is not a fan of this recipe. I bought the highest end canned tuna, packed in oil, soaked and rinsed the anchovy, and I like anchovies, which is why I could manage one anchovy. But for me, I did not like the result of this recipe, for the first time in the NYT Food section, I actually trashed it. So- not to diss the fans, but I thought it would be ethical to express that at least one person, (me), did not care for it.
PortlandShannon
This was great - no yogurt for my non-dairy daughter. Didn’t miss it. Used mini peppers, roasted and cut in half as an appetizer. Perfect.
Claire Emilie
Exactly what I needed this exceedingly hot evening. Very tasty, bright and easy to make. I had it with rosé and chickpea flour crackers. P.E.R.F.E.C.T!!!!
Alex
Easy & delish. Lots of way to modify it for your taste. Yum!
Alyson
Quick and simple, but absolutely delicious! I will be making this weekly.The garlic, caper, anchovy paste is so versatile. I could see this as an addition to chicken and pasta. I didn't have parsley, so I used dill. I think chives would have worked nicely too as a bit green and for some more flavour if you needed a substitute. Put it on nice toast if you don't have peppers, but the peppers make it even better.
Alex
I omitted the olive oil and greek yogurt and squeezed a full lemon into the tuna. Roasted the bell pepper before broiling a bit. Served on a bed of arugula. Absolutely delicious.
Kimberly
I've made this all summer -- it's our staple lunch on hot days. I make it the centerpiece of the Salade Niçoise, using the recipe for the creamy Salade Niçoise dressing also by Martha Rose Shulman on this NYTimes website. I do spice it up a little with chives and dill, as another reviewer suggested. And sometimes if I'm feeling saucy, I'll add in a pinch of cayenne.
Helane
Added some chopped celery and small halved cherry tomatoes. Dill instead of parsley. Great lunch
Carmen
If you’re out of red peppers, avocados work really well, too. The sweetness balances out the anchovies really nicely.
Alex
I didn't have yogurt and it was still delicious. Just added a little more olive oil and lemon. So simple and delicious. Great lunch!
Carmen
Amazing with roasted red peppers, chopped parsley, and a little bit of crumbled feta.
Karen L Davis
Hmmm. Loved the roasted pepper base. Salad a little looser than the in the pic, even with refrigeration. Next time might use a bit less lemon juice (2t)? Rather than taking the mortar and pestle route, used anchovy paste and added salt to the garlic press while crushing it. On tasting, felt tuna was a bit bland, so added a bit of both fresh, snipped dill and chives. Better.
Susan Alexander
Terrific. A nice change from the standard tuna salad. Used jarred roasted peppers which were fine. Could also use a scooped out tomato. Perfect for lunch or as an appetizer - follow with Chicken Provencal for example. Will definitely make again. PS I am addicted to anchovies so not optional for me.
Private notes are only visible to you.